Sample | Reaction time (min) | Reaction temp. (°C) | Catalyst | Oil to alcohol ratio | FAEE/ FAME conv. (%) | Equipment | Mode | Ref |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Vegetable/edible oils | ||||||||
Coconut oil* | 0.5 | 79.5 | NaOH | 1:9 Ethanol | 100 | Domestic Microwave | Continuous | |
0.75 | 82.2 | NaOH | 1:9 Ethanol | 100 | Â | Continuous | ||
1 | 83.4 | NaOH | 1:9 Ethanol | 100 | Â | Continuous | ||
Rice bran oil* | 0.5 | 77.8 | NaOH | 1:9 Ethanol | 93.5 | Â | Continuous | Â |
0.75 | 80.4 | NaOH | 1:9 Ethanol | 93.2 | Â | Continuous | ||
1 | 83.4 | NaOH | 1:9 Ethanol | 93.1 | Â | Continuous | ||
0.75 | 81.2 | NaOH | 1:9 Ethanol | 83.9 | Â | Continuous | ||
1 | 84.1 | NaOH | 1:9 Ethanol | 90.6 | Â | Continuous | ||
Vegetable oil (Triolein) | 3.5 | 50 | NaOH | 1:6 Methanol | 98 | Â | Batch | [124] |
Soybean oil | 10 | 65 | Ba(OH)2 H2O | 1:9 Methanol | 97.8 | Milestone Ethos 1600, 1000 W | Batch | [125] |
Rapeseed oil | 10 | 103 | Ba(OH)2 H2O (1.5%) | 1:9 Methanol | 99 | Â | Batch | [132] |
Rapeseed oil | 15 | 60 | Ba(OH)2 H2O (1.5%) | 1:9 Methanol | 98 | Â | Batch | [132] |
Rapeseed oil | 0.5 | 65 | NaOH (0.1%) | 1:30 Methanol | 89 | Â | Batch | [122] |
3 | 65 | NaOH (0.1%) | 1:30 Methanol | 92 | Â | Batch | ||
5 | 65 | NaOH (0.1%) | 1:30 Methanol | 94 | Â | Batch | ||
16 | 65 | NaOH (0.1%) | 1:30 Methanol | 99 | Â | Batch | ||
Sunflower | 16 | 65 | NaOH (1.0%) | 1:30 Methanol | 99 | Â | Batch | Â |
Soybean oil | 20 | 60 | NaOH (0.15%) | 1:5 Methanol | 98 | Â | Batch | [106] |
Soybean oil | 20 | 65 | NaOH (0.15%) | 1:9 Ethanol | 98 | Â | Batch | [106] |
Rice bran oil | 20 | 60 | NaOH (0.15%) | 1:5 Methanol | 98 | Â | Batch | [106] |
Rice bran oil | 20 | 60 | NaOH (0.15%) | 1:9 Ethanol | 97 | Â | Batch | [106] |
Rice bran oil | 10 | 50 | NaOH (0.6%) | 1:5 Ethanol | 99 | Â | Continuous | [133] |
Rice bran oil | 10 | 73 | NaOH (0.6%) | 1:5 Ethanol | 99 | Â | Continuous | [133] |
Soybean oil | 10 | 50 | NaOH (0.6%) | 1:5 Ethanol | 98 | Â | Continuous | [133] |
Soybean oil | 10 | 73 | NaOH (0.6%) | 1:5 Ethanol | 99 | Â | Continuous | [133] |
Vegetable oil | 2 | 50 | KOH (0.6%) | 1:6 Methanol | 98 | CEM Mars | Continuous | [130] |
Cottonseed | 7 | 333 | KOH (1.5%) | 1:6 Methanol | 92.4 | 21% of 1200W | Â | [64] |
Safflower seed oil | 6 | 333 | NaOH (1%) | 1:10 Methanol | 98.4 | 300W | Â | [135] |
Rapeseed & soybean | 1 | 333 | NaOH (1.3%) | 1:18 Methanol | 97 | 300W | Â | [136] |
Soybean | 1 | 333 | NaOH (1.3%) | 1:27 Methanol | 95 | 300W | Â | [136] |
Diphenylammonium salts:DPAMs (Mesylate) (10 molar) | Â | 100 | Â | Â | ||||
Corn | 20 | 150 C | DPABs (Benzenesulfonate) (10 molar) | 2goil:5g Methanol | 96 | Â | Â | [137] |
DPATs (Tosylate) (10 molar) | 100 | Â | Â | |||||
DPAMs (10 molar) | 2goil:5g | 92 | Â | Â | Â | |||
Soybean | 20 | 150 | DPABs (10 molar) | Methanol | 97 | Â | Â | [137] |
Soybean | 60 | 338 | Nan CaO (heterogeneous) | 1:7 Methanol | 96.6 | - | Â | [142] |
Soybean | 20 | 60 | Sulfated zirconia (5%) | 1:20 Methanol | 90 | Â | Â | [143] |
Oleic acid | 20 | 60 | Sulfated zirconia (5%) | 1:20 Methanol | 90 | Â | Â | [143] |
Canola | 5 | 100 | ZnO/La2O2CO3 (1%) | 1:1(W/W) Methanol | 95 | - | Â | [148] |
Camelina | - | - | BaO (1.5%), SrO (2%) | 1:9 Methanol | 94, 80 | 800W | Â | [118] |
Soybean | 2 | 333 | NaOH(1%) | 1:6 Methanol | 97.7 | 900W | Â | [152] |
Sunflower | 45 | - | Â | H2SO4 (0.05%) | 96.2 | 400 | Â | [154] |
Sunflower | 25 | - | TiO2/SO4 (0.02%) | 1:12 Methanol | 94.3 | 300 | Â | [155] |
Vegetable oil | 2 | 50 | KOH (0.6%) | 1:6 Methanol | 98 | CEM Mars | Continuous | [130] |
Waste vegetable oils/non-edible oils | ||||||||
Waste vegetable oil (domestic) | 1 | 65 | KOH | 1:9 Methanol | 96 | Start S Milestone | Batch | [120] |
Waste vegetable oil (restaurant) | 1 | 65 | KOH | 1:9 Methanol | 94.5 | Â | Batch | |
Kerosene used palm oil | ||||||||
mixture* | 0.5 | Â | NaOH | 1:9 Ethanol | 70.9 | Â | Â | [122] |
0.75 | 76.5 | NaOH | 1:9 Ethanol | 91.5 | Domestic Microwave | Continuous | ||
1 | 80.2 | NaOH | 1:9 Ethanol | 91.6 | Â | Continuous | ||
Used vegetable oil | 0.15 | Â | NaOH (1%) | 1:9 Ethanol | 100 | Â | Â | [123] |
Used palm oil* | 0.5 | 77.5 | NaOH | 1:9 Ethanol | 82.5 | Â | Continuous | |
2.3:1.27 (g:mL) | ||||||||
Unknown | 1 | 60 | NaOH | Methanol | 97 | CEM Explorer | Batch | [129] |
Waste vegetable oil | 6 | 50 | KOH | 1:6 Methanol | 96 | CEM Explorer | Batch | [130] |
Waste frying oil | 5 | 64 | NaOH (1%) | 1:6 Methanol | 93.36 | 600w | Â | [138] |
Macauba | 15 | 30 | Novozyme 435 (2.5%) | 1:9 Ethanol | 45.2 | Â | Â | |
5 | 40 | Lipozyme IM (5%) | 1:9 Ethanol | 35.8 | ||||
Waste frying oil | 0.5 | - | NaOH (3%) | 1:12 Ethanol | 97 | 800W | Â | [139] |
Rapeseed | 5 | 323 | KOH (1%) | 1:6 Methanol | 93.7 | 67% of 1200W | Â | [141] |
Rapeseed | 3 | 313 | NaOH (1%) | 1:6 Methanol | 92.7 | 67% of 1200W | Â | [141] |
Karanja | 150s | - | KOH | 33.4% (W/W) | 89.9 | 180W | Â | [144] |
Jatropha | 2 | 65 | KOH (1.5%) | 1:7.5 Methanol | 97.4 | - | Â | [145] |
Palm oil | 5 | 70 | KOH (1.5%) | 1:8.5 Ethanol | 98 | 70W | Â | [146] |
Yello horn | 10 | 60 | Heteropolyacid (HPAs) (1%) | 1:12 Methanol | 96.2 | 500W | Â | [147] |
Castorbean | 5 | - | Al2O3/50% KOH (1%) | 1:6 Methanol | 95 | 40 | Â | [149] |
Castorbean | 30 | - | SiO2/50% H2SO4 (1%) | 1:6 Methanol | 95 | 40 | Â | [149] |
Castorbean | 25 | - | SiO2/30% H2SO4 (1%) | 1:6 Methanol | 95 | 220 | Â | [149] |
Castor | 60 | 338 | H2SO4 | 1:12 Methanol | 94 | 200 | Â | [111] |
Triolin | 1 | 323 | KOH (5%) | 1:6 Methanol | 98 | 25 | Â | [150] |
1 | 323 | NaOH (5%) | 1:6 Methanol | 98 | 25 | Â | [150] | |
Frying oil | 4 | 60 | NaOH (0.5%) | 1:6 Methanol | 87 | 50% of 750W | Â | [151] |
Rapeseed | 4 hr | 310 | - | 1:2.5 Methanol | 91 | - | Â | [128] |
Safflower | 16 | 60 | NaOH (1%) | 1:10 Methanol | 98.4 | 300W | Â | [135] |
Maize | - | - | NaOH (1.5%) | 1:10 Methanol | 98 | - | Â | [153] |
Jatropha | 7 | 328 | NaOH (4%) | 1:30 Methanol | 86.3 | - | Â | [127] |